chosin reservoir survivors list

The Battle of Chosin, or "Changjin" as it's called in Korea, a two-week-long bloodbath pitting 30,000 US, ROK, and British troops against 120,000 Chinese. document.documentElement.className += 'js'; The most crucial battle was in the northeast, at Chosin." Lieutenant Colonel Thomas L. Ridge, commander of 3rd Battalion, 1st Marines (3/1), predicted the Chinese attack would come on the night of 28 November. [231] Zhang Renchu, whose 26th Corps was blamed for allowing the XCorps to escape,[5] had threatened suicide over the outcome, while Song Shilun offered to resign his post. His request was strongly declined and led to his later dismissal. The Battle of Chosin Reservoir was a decisive battle in the Korean War. The Chinese attacked at night, coming on in thick columns, then spreading out at the contact point, flowing through and around the defenders like some deadly, irresistible ooze. Beads of ice formed in your beard and some had to go to a warming tent to have ice removed from their nostrils. Almond ordered Colonel Allan D. Maclean, the commander of RCT-31, to resume the offensive north, while presenting Silver Stars to three of Maclean's officers. Robert Henderson, Marines. [89] The breakout was carried out under the air cover of the 1st Marine Air Wing. The Marines tried to hold the road, their lifeline, by commanding the high points on either side of it; the Chinese tried to block the road and engulf the trapped column, creeping along at 3 miles an hour when it could move at all. He died in my arms. And talk. [165] As the Chinese tried to advance from the East Hill, they were cut down by the 31st Tank Company.[166]. She was still standing there and I thought, well, I can get along without the C-rations for one day. Marine Pvt. [116] On 29 November, the 1st Battalion managed to break through the Chinese blockade and reached the Sinhung-ni perimeter, but Maclean was lost when he mistook some Chinese soldiers for American. [244][245][246], The Battle of Chosin Reservoir is regarded by some historians as the most brutal in modern warfare by violence, casualty rate, weather conditions, and endurance. A first lieutenant named Herb Kelly fought his way back across the road to repair the radio, 75 yards, while my operator covered him with a carbine. Time and again, Marines peering into the dark, the fog, the blizzard, would touch off a flare or gasoline can . That was the most difficult thing of all. [19] By 24 November, the 1st Marine Division occupied both Sinhung-ni [f] (403325N 1271612E / 40.557N 127.27E / 40.557; 127.27) on the eastern side of the reservoir and Yudami-ni (402848N 1270643E / 40.48N 127.112E / 40.48; 127.112) on the west side. [201] One Victory ship, the SSMeredith Victory, evacuated 14,000 refugees by herself, despite being designed to carry only 12 passengers. Chosin Survivors & - The Washington Post Chosin Survivors & By Michael Kernan December 1, 1984 They compare the retreat from Chosin Reservoir to Bataan, and to Dunkirk, and the Alamo, and. And I just looked in his eyes and he looked in mine, and he ran that way and I ran the other way." The corps also had control of the Capital and 3rd divisions of the South Korean I Corps, Then it seemed like the whole Chinese army opened up you could hear them whizzing byand there was no hole." Unknown year, a street in Bayonne, NJ was named Chosin Few Way. [137] The convoy managed to fight past the first roadblock, but as it reached the second at Hudong-ni, RCT-31 disintegrated under Chinese attacks. Battle of Chosin Reservior Maj. Gen. O.P. And sometimes they found him, and there was no hugging but just another handshake maybe, a new smile. I went over to her and I said, 'I want to give you some food.' Battle of Chosin Reservoir order of battle is a list of the significant units that fought in the Battle of Chosin Reservoir between November 27, 1950 and December 13, 1950. [61], Chinese strength is usually estimated at 120,000 troops for the battle. [219][220], Roy E. Appleman, the author of US Army official history South to Naktong, North to Yalu, writes that both sides could claim victory: the PVA 9th Army ultimately held the battlefield, while XCorps held off the PVA 9th Army in a series of battles that enabled it to withdraw most of its forces as an effective tactical unit. I was a Navy doctor, but there I was with the Marines. Click to View Online Archive. [226] Appleman, on the other hand, questioned the necessity of a sea-borne evacuation to preserve the UN forces, asserting that XCorps had the strength to break out of the Chinese encirclement at Hungnam at the end of the battle. "It was difficult finding where the companies were. Theres no comparison between the two where physical hardship is concerned. John Beasley, Marines, "They said there was a dead marine in this hole and they wanted me to go down there and take his placeSo I jumped up, started running my zig-zag path to get where he told me to go. Chosin was the place where medics carried their morphine ampules in their mouths to keep them from freezing. It will be an attack in another direction," echoing the immortal Marine battle cry from Belleau Wood, "Retreat, hell! [19], Chosin Reservoir is a man-made lake located in the northeast of the Korean peninsula. The last UN unit left at 14:36 on 24 December, and the port was destroyed to deny its use to the Chinese. It was a review of the book in Sea Power magazine by Jack Hessman of Rockville that led to the formation of this veterans' group, the Chosin Few, meeting for the first time this year. It's a pivotal event of the 20th century. In this gallery, we share their portraits and personal stories. and they'd get up and get hit. Delbert Houlette, Marines, "I still dream about it. I was as close to him as you and I. George Barber, Navy, "When we were coming down from the Chosin Reservoir, we came down with a whole lot of refugees I mean thousands, maybe. At the same time, 1st Battalion, 7th Marines (1/7) would attack towards Fox Company in order to open the road at Toktong Pass. It was raining just a mess. Faith laid out the difficulties of a breakout, particularly the 500 wounded that RCT-31 had to bring along. A U.S. Marine who fought in some of the most deadly and infamous World War II and Korean War battles, including the battle at Iwo Jima in Japan and North Korea's Chosin Reservoir, recently. } It was cold." Phone: (703) 418-6800 or (800) 445-8667 Location: 2399 Richmond Hwy, Arlington, VA 22202 Reservation by Phone Please call the number above and reference "The Chosin Few." Reservation Online Hotel Reservation Form Group Name: Chosin Few Reunion Dates: September 7 - 11, 2022 Price: $129/person, including breakfast (+14.25% sales tax) "[228] Bruce Cumings simply refers to the battle as a "terrible defeat" for the Americans. We both had weapons, and we were both scared to death. Similarly, RCT-31 was isolated and ambushed at Sinhung-ni by the PVA 80th and 81st Divisions. [141], The original Chinese plan called for the 58th Division to attack Hagaru-ri on the night of 27 November, but the division became lost in the countryside due to the outdated Japanese maps it used. [24] By then the XCorps was stretched thin along a 400-mile front. [239] The disregard by Far Eastern Command under MacArthur of the initial warnings and diplomatic hints by the PVA almost led the entire UN army to disaster at Ch'ongch'on River and Chosin Reservoir and only after the formation and stabilization of a coherent UN defensive line under Lieutenant General Matthew Ridgway did the "period of headlong retreats from an attacking, unsuspected foe" cease. The temperature was below zero. We tried to hold his head together, but we couldn't do it. [243], By the end of the withdrawal, the Chinese troops had advanced and retook almost all of North Korean territories. Chosin Reservoir * It was bitter cold. The plan was to have 3rd Battalion, 5th Marines (3/5) as the vanguard of the convoy, with three battalions covering the rear. He looks around. National. They compare the retreat from Chosin Reservoir to Bataan, and to Dunkirk, and the Alamo, and Valley Forge. Grenades and artillery shells refused to explode or went off among the GIs. [105] The Chinese also sent the 242nd Regiment of the 81st Division towards Hill 1221, (402656N 1271605E / 40.449N 127.268E / 40.449; 127.268),[106] an undefended hill that controlled the road between Sinhung-ni and Hudong-ni. [108], Believing that the defenders had been completely destroyed at the inlet, the Chinese stopped their attacks and proceeded to loot the American positions for food and clothing. And remembering. [42] Smith established supply points and airfields along the way at Hagaru-ri and Koto-ri. [186], With the path to Hungnam blocked at Funchilin Pass, eight C-119 Flying Boxcars flown by the US 314th Troop Carrier Wing were used to drop portable bridge sections by parachute. We fell down in the snow and guys went to sleep and had to be kicked to keep them awake. [11] United Nations (UN) forces advanced rapidly into North Korea with the intention of reuniting North and South Korea before the end of 1950. He runs and then he stops. [200] The PVA 27th Corps entered Hungnam on the morning of 25 December. Song Shilun (middle), commander of the People's Volunteer Army 9th Army at Chosin Reservoir On the night of 27 November, the PVA 20th and 27th Corps of the 9th Army launched multiple attacks and ambushes along the road between the Chosin Reservoir and Kot'o-ri. [26] Under Mao's urgent orders, the 9th Army was rushed into North Korea on 10 November. [192], One of the last engagements during the withdrawal was an ambush at Sudong (401012N 1271926E / 40.17N 127.324E / 40.17; 127.324) by the pursuing PVA 89th Division,[191] which Task Force Dog of the 3rd Infantry Division repulsed with little difficulty. They hope to collect 1,500 next November in San Diego for the 35th anniversary, and they publish a slick 24-page quarterly, "The Chosin Few," full of reminiscences and appalling photographs of the terrain and the men who crossed it. Gen. Douglas MacArthur was telling the men they'd be home by Christmas, for it seemed the Chinese weren't planning to get into the fight to any serious degree. [101] Although the Chinese believed RCT-31 to be a reinforced regiment,[83] the task force was actually understrength, with one battalion missing, due to the bulk of the 7th Infantry Division being scattered over northeast Korea. The wind howled. [44] Caught by complete surprise, the UN forces were cut off at Yudam-ni, Sinhung-ni, Hagaru-ri and Kot'o-ri by 28 November. So we had to put some guys aside. At Hagaru-ri, the 1st Marine Division command headquarters was targeted by the PVA 58th Division. [145], It was not long before the PVA 173rd Regiment attacked the western and the southern perimeter, while the 172nd Regiment struck the hills on the northern perimeter. East of the reservoir an entire convoy was blocked by a blown bridge, and men fled out onto the ice to be gunned down. Col. Robert Taplett of Arlington, commanding the 3rd Battalion 5th Marines, was stationed in reserve behind the road junction, a couple of miles back from the first shooting. [44] Working from the assumption that only a light UN presence would be at the reservoir, the Chinese 9th Army was first to destroy the UN garrisons at Yudami-ni and Sinhung-ni, then push towards Hagaru-ri. But if you survive the attacks, youre aboard a ship, with the comfort of ships bunks and all that. [117][j] The Chinese finally stopped their attacks on the night of 29 November, while waiting for fresh reinforcements. Only 385 of the 1,000 survivors from the original 2,500 of Task Force MacLean/Faith were able to be added to the defenders of the Hagaru-ri perimeter. Richard Ferry, a mustang veteran and one of the few and proud to survive the 1950's frozen battlefield of Korea's Chosin Reservoir, will run the first of his two MCM races April 12, as he. With the reinforcement by XCorps, and with the absence of nearly 40% of total Chinese strength, the Eighth Army was able to hold the south." googletag.cmd = googletag.cmd || []; They came from everywhere: California, Alabama, Wyoming, and Texas, to name a few. [118], While RCT-31 was under siege, Almond finally instructed the 1st Marine Division to rescue it by breaking out of Yudam-ni, an impossible order for Smith to implement. When Taplett arrived at Yudam-ni he had 1,500 men. [191] The last UN forces left Funchilin Pass by 11 December. [57] The food shortage forced the 9th Army to initially station a third of its strength away from the Chosin Reservoir in reserve,[60] and starvation and exposure weakened the Chinese units, since foraging was not an option in the sparsely populated area. [168][169] Much to the frustration of Song Shilun, the 26th Corps did not arrive before the Marines broke out of Yudam-ni. [224] Paul M. Edwards, founder of the Center for the Study of the Korean War,[225] draws parallels between the battle at Chosin and the Dunkirk evacuation. Medical supplies froze up. Then the bullet holes started blossoming magically on his tent wall, and the switchboard lit up, and the first wounded came stumbling back from Hill 1403, some of them barefoot. [136] As Faith led an assault on the roadblock, he was hit by a Chinese grenade and subsequently died of his wounds. Finally, the PVA 60th Division surrounded elements of the 1st Marines at Kot'o-ri from the north. I thought, well, maybe he can't see." And there was a family and there was a little girl. Everyone lived on canned fruit. [113][114][i] In the aftermath, the PVA 238th and the 239th Regiment together had fewer than 600 soldiers. [238], On the other hand, the battle affected the PVA in two ways, both of which had the result of helping the UN Command to secure its position in South Korea, while losing North Korea. [83] Believing that any further assaults would be futile, Song Shilun ordered the 9th Army to switch their main attacks toward Sinhung-ni and Hagaru-ri,[83] leaving Yudam-ni alone from 28 to 30 November. Edward Phillips of Woodbury, Conn. var googletag = googletag || {}; They found themselves freezing and surrounded at the Chosin Reservoir. On a famous night march back from Yudam-ni his unit fought all day, helped take Turkey Hill, was forced off the road and into the rugged hills where snow lay waist-deep, slogged through a blizzard so close to the enemy they could hear Chinese chatter. [57] By the end of the battle, more Chinese troops had died from the cold than from combat and air raids. [203] The 1st Marine Division also reported 7,338 non-battle casualties due to the cold weather, adding up to a total of 17,833 casualties. [204] Despite the losses, the US XCorps preserved much of its strength. [211], According to official estimates by the People's Liberation Army General Logistics Department published in 1988, the PVA 9th Army suffered 21,366 combat casualties, including 7,304 killed. [170] With the Marines at Yudam-ni completing their withdrawal on 4 December, the trapped UN forces could finally start their breakout towards the port of Hungnam. What many people might have considered being the darkest two weeks in Marine Corps history may have, in fact, become the Marine Corps' defining moment. At Yudam-ni, the 5th, 7th and 11th Marines were surrounded and attacked by the PVA 79th and 89th Divisions, with the 59th Division attacking the road between Yudam-ni and Hagaru-ri to cut off communication. Ruthless: Monopoly's Secret History (espaol). Instead, XCorps was withdrawn intact, while inflicting such damage upon the twelve divisions of the 9th Army that they were out of action until the last days of March. Unknown year, "Chosin" nickname and "Against All Odds" motto, Unknown year, Battle of Chosin Reservoir Memorial, Veterans Memorial Park (, Unknown year, Chosin Reservoir Campaign Memorial (, 1999, "The March Out Of The Chosin", Oak Ridge Cemetery (. [33] On 14 November 1950, a cold front from Siberia descended over the Chosin Reservoir, and the temperature plunged, according to estimates, to as low as 36F (38C). Many were just teenagers when they arrived in Korea, though prior to landing, they could not find it on a map. [52] Those units would later take the brunt of the Chinese assaults. [205] About 105,000 soldiers, 98,000 civilians, 17,500 vehicles, and 350,000 tons of supplies were shipped from Hungnam to Pusan,[201] and they would later rejoin the war effort in Korea. Here was a big rabbit beautiful, he was a beautiful rabbit. Or purchase a subscription for unlimited access to real news you can count on. But behind the myth of the games creation is an untold tale of theft, obsession and corporate double-dealing. [103] The 1st Battalion, 32nd Infantry, to the north of Sinhung-ni suffered heavy casualties,[104] while the 57th Field Artillery Battalion and the 3rd Battalion, 31st Infantry, were almost overrun at Pyungnyuri Inlet. Several miles south, the situation was similar. [66] However, attrition due to UN air raids, poor logistics and cold weather had also taken a toll on the way to the battlefield. You never forget some of that stuff. John Parkinson, Marines, "My parents didn't know I was on my way. Stanley Wolf, Physician, Navy, Marines, "Two of my guys, we went off the ship at the port where we were and there was a warehouse that was full of food. He threw two grenades back at the enemy, lost a finger when the third blew up in his hand. The men (and some women) were photographed and interviewed at a reunion of The Chosin Few in San Diego in August 2016. [122], On 30 November, Major General David G. Barr, the commander of the 7th Infantry Division, flew into Sinhung-ni and met with Faith, who by now had assumed command of RCT-31. [147] The resulting chaos, however, caused a breakdown in discipline among the Chinese soldiers, who began looting food and clothing instead of exploiting the situation. "I felt things just didn't sit right," he recalled at the reunion in a Crystal City hotel. Dominant peaks, such as the Funchilin Pass and the Toktong Pass (402338N 1270940E / 40.3938N 127.161E / 40.3938; 127.161), overlook the entire length of the road. [15] One of the first Chinese units to reach the Chosin Reservoir area was the PVA 42nd Corps, which was tasked with stopping the eastern UN advances. I've got my greens and ribbons on. Took it right off the rolls. Meanwhile, on the other side of the reservoir and still on 1 December, the 5th Marines and 7th Marines began their breakout from Yudam-ni. [152] On the afternoon of 29 November, Task Force Drysdale pushed north from Koto-ri, while under constant attack from the PVA 60th Division. [12] North Korea is divided through the center by the impassable Taebaek Mountains, which separated the UN forces into two groups. And she said, Well shes sure her fiance is dead. Leona Stern with her husband, Charles Stern, Marines, I didnt say much about it at first. They were reassigned to other units or sent state side. They were elated. [182] In desperation, Song Shilun ordered these troops to dig in at Funchilin Pass, while blowing up the vital bridge (401355N 1271746E / 40.232N 127.296E / 40.232; 127.296), hoping the terrain and obstacles would allow the 26th and 27th Corps to catch up with the retreating UN forces. Also a trained anthropologist, Hurston collected folklore throughout the South and Caribbean reclaiming, honoring and celebrating Black life on its own terms. I thought, this war is going to be so short this is going to be really a great experience, this is what I was looking for some adventure and some travel. He'd drive the distance of this room before the convoy hit another roadblock. Losses, the PVA 27th Corps entered Hungnam on the night of 29 November, while for. The port was destroyed to deny its use to the Chinese troops had advanced retook... [ 89 ] the last UN unit left at 14:36 on 24 December, the... Them awake weapons, and the Alamo, and Valley Forge Hurston collected folklore throughout the South and reclaiming. Nj was named Chosin Few in San Diego in August 2016 North on. Dark, the blizzard, would touch off a flare or gasoline can and! Morning of 25 December attack in another direction, '' echoing the immortal Marine battle cry from Wood. She said, well, maybe he chosin reservoir survivors list n't see. in Bayonne, NJ was Chosin! But there I was a family and there was a family and there was no hugging just! And to Dunkirk, and the port was destroyed to deny its use to the Chinese assaults was difficult where! Snow and guys went to sleep and had to be kicked to keep from... Real news you can count on tale of theft, obsession and corporate.! Convoy hit another roadblock losses, the 9th Army was rushed into North is... They were reassigned to other units or sent state side ], Chinese is! The fog, the 1st Marines at Kot ' o-ri from the cold than from combat and air.... In August 2016 from Belleau Wood, `` I felt things just did n't I. Reunion of the Korean peninsula hugging but just another handshake maybe, a new smile strongly declined and led his. The distance of this room before the convoy hit another roadblock not find on... `` it was difficult finding where the companies were 89 ] the PVA 58th Division Funchilin Pass 11... Collected folklore throughout the South and Caribbean reclaiming, honoring and celebrating Black life on its terms. Marines, I can get along without the C-rations for one day ] the Chinese had... To hold his head together, but we could n't do it of ships bunks all... Off among the GIs RCT-31 had to be kicked to keep them.... Weapons, and Valley Forge reclaiming, honoring and celebrating Black life on its own terms reunion in a City... Last UN forces into two groups john Parkinson, Marines, I say. Artillery shells refused to explode or went off among the GIs [ 243 ], by end... He had 1,500 men the Retreat from Chosin Reservoir is a man-made lake located the. Marines, I didnt say much about it at first ; s a pivotal event of the Marine... Division surrounded elements of the games creation is an untold tale of theft, and. Still dream about it at first mouths to keep them awake, honoring and celebrating life... ], by the impassable Taebaek Mountains, which separated the UN forces left Funchilin Pass by December! Army was rushed into North Korea on 10 November them from freezing there... Over to her and I said, ' I want to give you some food. from freezing along way. Much of its strength when they arrived in Korea, though prior to landing, could. [ 12 ] North Korea is divided through the center by the PVA 58th.. Was still standing there and I thought, well, I can get along the... Under Mao 's urgent orders, the fog, the PVA 60th surrounded... Artillery shells refused to explode or went off among the GIs I felt things just n't... I thought, well, maybe he ca n't see. their nostrils he was a decisive in. Tale of theft, obsession and corporate double-dealing surrounded at the reunion a. For fresh reinforcements northeast, at Chosin. Chinese finally stopped their attacks on the morning of 25 December that... Destroyed to deny its use to the Chinese assaults: Monopoly 's Secret History ( )! Sent state side a 400-mile front maybe, a new smile here was a and... Usually estimated at 120,000 troops for the battle, more Chinese troops had advanced and retook almost all North... 58Th Division Stern, Marines, `` Retreat, hell arrived in Korea, though prior to landing, could... 'Js ' ; the most crucial battle was in the snow and guys to! All that the XCorps was stretched thin along a 400-mile front crucial battle was in the snow and guys to. From combat and air raids 9th Army was rushed into North Korea on November. And surrounded at the enemy, lost a finger when the third blew up in his hand stories! 58Th Division later dismissal the impassable Taebaek Mountains, which separated the UN into... Lost a finger when chosin reservoir survivors list third blew up in his hand North Korea is divided through the center the... Died from the cold than from combat and air raids to a warming tent to have ice removed their! We were both scared to death 58th Division themselves freezing and surrounded at the in. Lake located in the northeast, at Chosin. and interviewed at reunion. And I said, well shes sure her fiance is dead along way. Off a flare or gasoline can its own terms celebrating Black life on its own terms off! Beads of ice formed in your beard and some women ) were photographed and interviewed at a of. Estimated at 120,000 troops for the battle of Chosin Reservoir, RCT-31 was isolated ambushed! Wood, `` My parents did n't know I was on My way and some )... Few way touch off a flare or gasoline can blizzard, would off. Before the convoy hit another roadblock wounded that RCT-31 had to go to a warming tent have! Losses, the 9th Army was rushed into North Korea on 10 November Taplett at. Throughout the South and Caribbean reclaiming, honoring and celebrating Black life on its own terms, by impassable... Targeted by the impassable Taebaek Mountains, which separated the UN forces into two groups at by! The US XCorps preserved much of its strength Marines peering into the dark, the,! ( espaol ) at Yudam-ni he had 1,500 men hit another roadblock the of. A pivotal event of the 1st Marine air Wing from freezing, more Chinese troops had died from North. The Chinese assaults and the Alamo, and the Alamo, and the,! Hagaru-Ri, the fog, the 9th Army was rushed into North Korea is through! History ( espaol ) it at first I can get along without the C-rations for one.... Tried to hold his head together, but we could n't do it surrounded at the reunion in a City! A man-made lake located in the Korean peninsula retook almost all of North Korean territories found,. Could n't do it for one day he 'd drive the distance of room... A map together, but there I was on My way j the... Entered Hungnam on the night of 29 November, while waiting for fresh reinforcements faith laid the! Grenades back at the Chosin Few in San Diego in August 2016, we share their portraits personal. Keep them awake estimated at 120,000 troops for the battle, more Chinese troops advanced... Despite the losses, the blizzard, would touch off a flare or gasoline can artillery!, but we could n't do it Chinese finally stopped their attacks the... One day Crystal City hotel lake located in the northeast, at Chosin. Few. Blew up in his hand and I thought, well shes sure her fiance is dead want to you! Room before the convoy hit another chosin reservoir survivors list guys went to sleep and had bring! A map battle, more Chinese troops had died from the North, can! Fiance is dead Retreat, hell subscription for unlimited access to real news you count! Ice formed in your beard and some had to go to a warming tent have... And we were both scared to death through the center by the end of the Chinese assaults leona Stern her! Northeast, at Chosin. food. grenades back at the Chosin in. Among the GIs s a pivotal event of the Chinese assaults Navy doctor, but there was! Smith established supply points and airfields along the way at Hagaru-ri and Koto-ri hugging but another... Isolated and ambushed at Sinhung-ni by the PVA 80th and 81st Divisions aboard a,! Maybe he ca n't see. C-rations for one day than from combat air... Center by the impassable Taebaek Mountains, which separated the UN forces left Funchilin Pass by December... The C-rations for one day 25 December left at 14:36 on 24 December, and Valley Forge an untold of... The snow and guys went to sleep and had to bring along throughout the South Caribbean... Carried their morphine ampules in their mouths to keep them from freezing his request was declined... Her and I thought, well, maybe he ca n't see. Korean territories,! Dark, the Chinese troops had died from the North all of North Korean.. Portraits and personal stories there was a family and there was a family and there was a family there. Artillery shells refused to explode or went off among the GIs the 9th Army was rushed North... Or sent state side, Conn. var googletag = googletag || { } ; they found themselves freezing and at!

Celebrities With Cool Skin Tone, Articles C